Caught in the Storm Page 11

  “You’re a monster for what you did to all of those women. Do you know some of them were mothers? You took mothers away from their children. Their children were never able to be held in their mother’s arms again. You did that; you took them away.”

  “They were all whores,” he panted. “They all leave; they only care about having a man’s cock between their legs. They should all die.”

  He screamed when the knife went through his upper thigh, imbedding itself in the table.

  She leaned down close to his ear, “You took my mother away. You’re a monster and you should die.”

  “I’m not a monster. They were my women. My women to do with whatever I wanted to. I can kill whomever I want. I have the power; you don’t.”

  “Oh, yes I do. Can you feel that? Can you feel your life’s blood draining from your body? You are going to die and there is nothing you can do about it.”

  “No, I’m not going to die. You’re wrong.”

  “My mother and father only stayed married because of me. My father was out drinking, and fucking anything with two legs while Mama was home with me. She loved me. I never doubted her love.” She took the knife and made two long deep cuts on the bottom of each of his feet. “I was her world, and I knew she’d always be there for me. Until you found her. You killed her. Dumped her on the side of the road like yesterday’s trash.”

  Grabbing a bottle of hand sanitizer, she rubbed it into the open wounds she’d just created; sliding her fingers in to make sure it went deep inside him. He couldn’t stand it any longer and screamed at the amount of pain flowing through his body.

  “Everything would be so different if she were still alive. You ruined my life. You ruined so many other people’s lives. You need to suffer.”

  Taking a handful of forks, she started moving around his body again, digging them into his skin and pulling it back to expose the muscle under the flesh. He started whimpering as each one was shoved into his flesh. Leaving the forks dangling by their weight, she occasionally knocked them to cause more pain. “Do you like that? How do you think those women felt when you did it to them?”

  Jeremy lost track of where he was, the pain making his thoughts confused. “I need to hide. They’re fighting again. I don’t want them to hurt me. I’ll be safe under the bed. I have all my special things there,” he whispered.

  Dana ignored the babbling words that were coming out of his mouth. Once she saw his blood appear for the first time, she knew she could do this. She could kill a man. With one hand, she reached over for the heavy duty gloves, putting them on over the latex gloves she was already wearing. Picking up the section of razor wire she had soaking in lemon juice with one hand, she grabbed his cock with the other. Using her fingers, she squeezed and spread the head of his cock so she had his hole exposed and she rammed the wire down it, all the while twisting as it went deeper before finishing up by wrapping the rest of it around his cock, pulling it tight until it was ripped away from his body.

  Jeremy had no idea what was going on; all he knew was he wanted his mommy. His mommy would make everything better. She always did. She said there would be no more pain; she’d make it all go away. He always felt safe in her arms. She smelled of Ivory soap and lemon. He could smell the lemon even now. He used to love sitting on her lap and playing with her hair. It was so soft.

  “Mommy! Make it stop. Please. Tell Daddy, I’ll be good.” Tears flowed as he gasped for air, his eyes open and blindly staring at the ceiling. “Mommy, I need you! Don’t leave me! Mommy! Mommy! Mommy! Nooooo! I don’t know what to do without you! Help me! Why did you leave? You can’t leave me here all alone! I’m so lost! Where are you?” His voice grew weaker and weaker as he tried to reach out to his mother, his tears drying on his face.

  There was nothing left for Dana to do. With the amount of blood he had lost and how incoherent he was, he should be dead soon. She retreated to the shadows where she had set up a chair, so she could watch him die without him knowing she was there. He deserved to think he was dying alone and no one would come to save him.

  Jackson woke up to see Kat sitting on the edge of the bed. With the dim light coming in from the hallway, he knew she wasn’t wearing what she typically slept in. “What’s up?” He tried to keep the fear out of his voice. It was something he battled with every time he fell asleep next to her; that she’d leave him and be gone when he woke up.

  “I thought I could do it,” she mumbled.

  With his heart in his throat, he asked, “Do what?”

  “Find him and kill him. Make him suffer. Maybe leave him there to bleed to death. But I can’t. I couldn’t even make it out the door.”

  Jackson’s mind spun with her words. Thinking back to the previous morning, she must have figured something else out, something the rest of them didn’t see. She had kept it from them and had planned on going out to kill Jeremy. “Why?”

  She turned to look at him. “Because you matter more to me than any kind of revenge. Because I know killing, him won’t change anything. Because I’m not that person. I couldn’t kill anyone. It wasn’t who I used to be.” She turned toward him. “Jackson, I want to be her again. I want you to know the carefree girl I used to be. I want us to have a future together. I was so caught up I couldn’t see anything else but ending what mattered most to him, his life.”

  He knew this was a huge step for her and he didn’t want to fuck this up. He sat up and laced his fingers through hers. “So what do you want to do?”

  “I need to find out if he’s there. It’s a long shot, but it’s all we’ve got.”

  “How did you figure out where to look?”

  She shrugged. “I was just staring at the map and noticed there are a lot of back roads that aren’t heavily populated. Then I remembered driving around when I was Lexi’s bodyguard. I wanted to know every possible escape route if I needed to get her to safety. I remembered there was a Tiffani Lane; at the time, I thought it was strange because it wasn’t the typical spelling of Tiffani. Then I remembered his first victim. There was a house for rent on that road. He’d love the significance of that.”

  “He would. But what if he sees us? What if he gets away again? Shouldn’t we just call the police?”

  “Would you be able to sit here and wonder if they’d caught him, if he’d somehow escaped again? And would they even look into it?”

  Sighing, Jackson knew she was right. He’d hate just sitting around and waiting. “Fine. Let’s go.”

  When he started to get up, she stopped him by throwing herself into his arms. She whispered in his ear, “I love you.”

  Those were the words he’d been waiting for. Hugging her close, he wanted her to be right, that Jeremy was there and they’d finally catch him so they could start their life, together. “Baby, I love you too.”

  Jackson and Kat parked down the road from the farmhouse on Tiffani Lane. Once they were out of the car, the wind picked up and she could smell rain in the air. Looking up, she saw the moon was disappearing behind fast moving clouds. She was starting to have second thoughts about coming out here in the middle of the night, when a storm was blowing in and they couldn’t use flashlights.

  “How are we going to get there?” she whispered to him.

  “Very carefully.”

  “No, really, try not to go into so much detail.”

  “Hey, you were the one who was going to come out here to begin with, shouldn’t you have an idea?”

  “You’d think. But I was kind of planning on the whole going in with guns blazing plan.”

  “And what if he wasn’t here. What if it were some family?”

  “I don’t know. I didn’t really think of that.”

  “Here, hold onto the back of my jeans. I’ve got a red LED flashlight. We aren’t going to be able to see much, but enough not to fall down an abandoned well. Try to be quiet, and step where I step.”

  “Sure. I can do that.” She rolled her eyes at him.

  He turned to her, and for a mom
ent, she thought he knew what she did. “And remember, if he’s there, we leave quietly and call the cops.”

  “No problem there. I’ve got my phone in one hand and the other is in your pants so we don’t have to worry about me going for my gun.”

  He nodded toward her phone. “It’s on silent, right? And we don’t have to worry about it lighting up for any reason, do we?”

  “Nope, it’s all good. Let’s get this over with.”

  Without another word, they started their hike to the house. After looking in the windows on the lower level, they could tell no one was living there. Jackson started to move away, but Kat tugged him back and pointed toward the barn. Shrugging, he turned and moved toward it. They were out in the middle of the open when lightning filled the sky. Kat jumped and pulled Jackson toward her. They both looked around, their eyes temporarily blinded. She closed her eyes in the hope they would adjust back to the darkness quicker.

  Large drops of rain started falling on them as thunder rumbled through the night. She shivered as the heavy droplets started to dampen her clothes. A freak fall thunderstorm was all they needed right now. They started walking toward the old barn. As they got closer, they could see where the wood was rotting and holes were appearing. Knowing they wouldn’t be able to see what was inside, did not stop them from finding two holes close to each other so they could look in. At that exact moment, lightning struck and illuminated a bloody mess of a body spread out on one of the tables in the barn.

  Kat gasped and walked backwards, still gripping Jackson’s jeans, pulling him back with her. “We’ve got to get out of here,” she whispered as her eyes darted around, wondering if Jeremy was somewhere around.

  “What if that person is still alive?” Jackson hissed back at her.

  The rain was coming down harder and mixing with the tears that were flowing freely from her eyes. “I can’t do this. I can’t go in there. Please don’t make me.”

  “I’ve got to see.” He grabbed her and gave her a little shake. “What if we can save that person? Don’t they deserve that?”

  Kat knew he was right, but the thought of going in there brought back too many memories. Shaking, she couldn’t focus her mind to come up with the correct answer. All the blood. Her lips felt numb and she could feel her heart pounding as she slowly blinked, trying to focus only on Jackson.

  “Kat, we’ve got to do this. You can stay here. Call the police. They’ll be on their way, but I’ve got to go in there.”

  She had no answer for him.

  “Kat, can you hear me.” After she finally nodded, he continued, “I’m going in. You call the police. Okay?”

  “Okay.”

  He kissed her quickly and turned, running toward the barn doors. It felt like she was watching everything in slow motion as he flung the barn doors open and the wind caught them. She flinched as they slammed against the side of the barn. She shook her head, trying to clear it. She lifted the phone she had gripped in her hand and dialed 9-1-1, never taking her eyes off Jackson.

  Her legs seemed to have a mind of their own. While she waited for the dispatcher to answer, they started moving and she found herself walking toward the barn. The closer she got, the more she started to notice a rancid smell. Not being able to identify it though, she kept walking even as the smell grew stronger.

  Jackson was using his phone as a flashlight and she could now see what shape the body was in. There could be no way the person was alive. She shuddered as she heard something dripping, not knowing whether it was the run-off of blood from the table or the rain on the roof.

  Lightning filled the barn and they had their first full look at the body. And its face. A face Kat knew all too well, a face that looked just like Anthony’s.

  Jeremy was dead and someone had tortured him. Tortured him to death.

  Dana moved quietly from her hiding space at the back of the barn. She had sat there in silence until he finally took his last breath, and then sat there a little longer. She couldn’t put her feelings into words. She had killed a monster. Women were not going to have to worry anymore about him finding them and killing them. She took revenge for her mother. There was nothing left to do; her work here was done.

  While Jackson and Kat were busy at the front of the barn learning that Jeremy was now dead, she snuck out the back and walked off into the woods, never looking back. She hummed to herself and thought about the other files she had back on her computer, wondering which one she should find next. Now she knew she could kill, there was nothing stopping her. There were too many men out there who preyed on women and children, using them, abusing them. They all needed to pay, and she was the one to hand out the justice the system was unable to deliver. Already, she had forgotten about the six and Jeremy, her mind moving on to who was next.

  They all huddled together on the porch of the old farmhouse. Light rain pattered on the roof. The doors of the barn were wide open and law enforcement were all over the place, collecting evidence. It was over. Jeremy was dead.

  “I still can’t believe it’s him. That he’s dead. We don’t have to worry anymore,” Lexi said.

  “Believe me, it’s true. Whoever did that to him didn’t touch his face. It was almost like they wanted to make sure he’d be positively identified.” Kat shook her head, trying to erase from her brain the memory of what he looked like.

  “But how would they know he’d be found?” Evie shook her arms and legs as if to use up some of the extra energy she had.

  Anthony looked up from the screen on his phone. “Jeremy was renting month to month. The landlord would have been here in a couple of days if he hadn’t paid. This place is hard to rent so the landlord didn’t check as carefully as he should have. A clean-cut man had enough cash to pay for the deposit, first and last month’s rent, so he took it.”

  “He was so close. All this time. Only ten minutes away from our home.” Lexi shivered and Noah wrapped his arms around her.

  One of the detectives in charge came out of the house and stopped to talk to them. “I know you’ve all been through a lot, so I’m going to keep you up to date on what’s been going on. We’ve found evidence in the house that he’s been keeping track of all of you. From what I understand, not as much as before, but what pictures he could take, were of you in public. There’s a lot of writing on the walls; it’s going to take a while to process it all. And quite frankly, I’m not sure if it would be anything you’d really want to read. Most of it doesn’t make any kind of sense.”

  “I don’t get it, how was he able to get our pictures? We had security all over the place.” Jackson’s hand gripped the railing so hard his knuckles turned white.

  “We found a lot of theater make-up and some men’s wigs. He could have been standing right next to you and you wouldn’t have known it.”

  “I so did not need to know that.” Evie glared at the detective.

  “Sorry, well, that’s about all we’ve found out from the house. I’m heading into the barn now. I’ll come back and talk to you soon.”

  “Thank you, detective.” Noah shook his hand before leaning back against the house, waiting for him to leave. “This is so surreal. It’s over.” He grabbed Lexi and hugged her tight. “It’s really over, love.”

  “It is.” A smile spread across Lexi’s face before it started to fade. “Is it wrong that I feel bad about being so happy someone is dead?”

  “Yes, it is wrong.” Evie sat on the railing. “I for one am happy the bastard is dead. Part of me wishes I could have been the one to do it.”

  “Evie!” Lexi scolded.

  “Lex, come on, he’s killed over a dozen women. He tried to kill you twice. He was planning on killing all three of us. When it comes down to it, either him or us, it was going to be him.”

  “Yes, but still Evie, he was a human being. No one deserves to die that way.”

  “He did.” Evie jutted out her chin.

  “Evie,” Jackson said quietly, “You didn’t see what was done to him up close. He
ll, we couldn’t even tell everything that was done because of all the blood. I don’t think he was dead that long. If we had been earlier, we might have caught the person who did this to him.”

  “Well then, it’s a good thing you weren’t any earlier,” Evie said and continued before Jackson could interrupt her, “If you had been here you might have stopped it. You might also be dead. The person who did this doesn’t want to be caught. Hello! And then what, Jeremy goes to jail? What if there’s some bleeding heart jury and he gets off, or doesn’t get as much time and he’s set free? No thank you, I’ll take him cold, dead and buried.” She folded her arms across her chest.

  Kat wasn’t sure how she felt. She was numb. Looking over at Anthony, she wondered how he was feeling. He was the one who had lost so much because of Jeremy. Killing him wouldn’t bring his parents back, his best friend or even the other women who’d had the misfortune to have Jeremy find interest in them.

  Needing to get away from Lexi, Evie and Jackson arguing about what everyone should be feeling, she walked down the stairs and over to the big oak tree. Leaning up against it, she looked up at the sky through the naked branches just in time to see a rainbow appear. She laughed without humor, thinking of the pain she had been through during and after the attack, both mental and physical, and how it still affected her. And now, there was Jeremy lying dead, tortured in the barn. Maybe worse than anything he had ever done to any woman. And it was over. No more looking back over her shoulder. No more thoughts of revenge running through her mind. It was over.

  “I can’t wrap my head around it either,” Anthony said. When she jumped, he continued, “Sorry, I didn’t mean to startle you.” He nodded in the direction of the porch where they were still arguing, “I needed to get away, just like you.”

  Kat looked up at him, behind him she could see the barn, and what was left of Jeremy. It was surreal to see both of them so close. She knew she had clung to her anger toward him for far too long. Now she knew every time she saw him, she would know instantly it was Anthony and not Jeremy, there would no longer be any wonder when he walked into the room. “He’s gone. It’s just you now.” She looked at him like she had never seen him before.